How do you think Jonas feels knowing that he can lie to others? If you were to choose one person that could share a memory with you, who would it be and why?
I think Jonas feels abnormal because until now the community wouldnt allow that,first time that Jonas i ''above'' the rules of the communti. I realy dont know maybe my father or mother beacause they are the closest people to me.
I would feel very weird because as Jonas I would have never lied before in my life. I would share a memory with my brother so he could see how he looked as a baby.
I think this just makes Jonas's experiance scarier because he is probably scared of what he has to lie about.I would want my dad to share a one of he's memorys because he has a very intersting life.
We think Jonas feels very wierd and indevidual beacuse all the others in his community are not allowed to lie and he can and he didn't lie before in he's entire life. We will choose to share our dreams to our sisters because they are allmost in our age and they can understand our way of thinking very well. by: Emmanuelle and MIa
I think Jonas feels a-little uncomforable knowing that he can lie to others and others can't because he seems like a good young man and I don't think he even wants to lie and I think that he doesn't want to be differrent from others (at least not more differrent than waht he is now). i think I would choose my friend "Li Zebba" beacause we are the best freinds in the world and we tell each-other everything and I know I can trust him because he trusts me.
I think Jonas feels different knowing he can lie from one side but from the other side he may be felt cheated because maybe other people got this saying that they can lie and maybe it could be his parents. I would choose my grandpa because he was in world wore two and I would like to know how was it there and how he survived.
I think Jonas is scared to lie. He was educated to not lie and he didn't.It is very scary that now one of the community's biggest rules can be broken easly. I am very interested in my dad's memories, and I would like to know some of his.
I think that Jonas felt weird and different because now he can do something that is not allowed to others, just for him. I think that hhe also felt like he is not going to use this rule to be fair but he is going to lie. I would choose my parents to see how their childhood was and to feel closer to them.
I think jonas feels wierd about the fact that he can, and sometimes will even NEED, to lie to others. he was grown on a place where you should'nt lie, because its breaking the rules of the community.
If I had to chose one person that will share his memories with me, I would prabobly chose some famous person because I'd like to know what its like to be famous.
- I think Jonas feels bad about being allowed to lie and maybe even guilty because he is almost the only one who is allowed to lie in the Community, and he has never lied before. - If I could choose one person to share memories with it would be my best friend. I moved to Israel about six months ago and she still lives in America and I would like to send her memories of my life in Israel.
Nir Ofek I think that Jonas was a good boy that following the rules all the time. But now, when he was selected to this special assigment, there was alot of new rules. He can't even imagine how his life would be if he could lie to people. He was confiused and felt uncomftabel. I would choose someone from my family that could share a memory with me, because its very interesting to hear a story life of someone that I know prettey good. I want to learn about my family background.
i think Jonas feels diffrent knowing he can lie because he never lied before, but i think he also feels Special because no one else could lie. if i were jonas i would feel diffrerent but in a good way. i would choose my mom because i am talking with her about every thing.she is helping me when i am sad and when i am happy she is supportive meand i love her more then anything.
i think that jonas would feel very weird that he can lie because he lived in a society in wich lying is a very bad thing. If I would have choose with whom to share my memories i would choose my mom because i would want to experience her memories too.
May Goldberg I think Jonas feel shocked and maybe a little afraid and betrayed. I think that because maybe he’ll think that if he allowed to lie other people allowed to lie, too, like his parents or the Chief Elder. I think that maybe Jonas would be afraid that other lied to him already. If I should choose one person that could share a memory with me I was choosing someone old, but not too old so he\she could clearly remember the memory, for example my grandmother.
I think Jonas is shocked and can't believe that he is allowed to lie, and he won't use it for a while. It was a shock to him because he was educated to not lie, it's like not allowed to buy anything that's more expensive than 10 dollarrs, and one day just get allowed, you won't use it. I would choose Messi, because I want to know what he thinks about Israel.
I think Jonas feels shocked and weird by the fact that he can lie. All of his life, he was raised not to lie, and now suddenly he might encounter a situation that he must lie. I think this change, is probably shocking and amazing for him. I would wish to be shared a memory from Julius Cesar, because I would like to experience those ancient times, and how being an emperor feels like.
I think Jonas feels freedom that now he doesn’t have to share his dreams and feelings, because if his personal thoughts and feelings will be published it would change people's attitude to him. I think that firstly it would be hard for Jonas to have the opportunity not telling the truth because all his life educated telling the truth. If I would choose someone that could share with me his memories I would choose someone old, with a fascinating life story, someone who passed many things in his life and there is much to learn from them or from him, someone who has a deferent perspective on life, not like mine.
I think jonas feels freedom and relieved because now he doesn't have to share his dreams anymore. I think he feels special and happy because usually he didn't like sharing his dreams and feelings and now knowing he doesn't have to do it anymore it's a good liberating feeling. The person I would share my memories and feeling is my mom. She os the closest and most important person for me. I trust her very much and feel comfortable sharing thing with her.
I think that when Jonas is given the permission to lie it makes him rather more separate than the other people, which surely makes him feel more uncomfortable, thinking and wondering of what could be if others had this permission too, and he could never know if what they say is true or false. If there was one person in the world that I had to share a memory with it would probably be my aunt, not only because I feel good and safe spending time with her, but also she has been in many different places, seen and done exciting things that I wish to know about and experience myself.
I think that Jonas, now that he can lie, thinks that all of his life, he lived in a lie (because everyone can lie). If I (as Jonas) could share a memory, I would share it with Asher, because he deserves to know what am I doing at the Annex room.
I think Jonas feels abnormal because until now the community wouldnt allow that,first time that Jonas i ''above'' the rules of the communti.
ReplyDeleteI realy dont know maybe my father or mother beacause they are the closest people to me.
I would feel very weird because as Jonas I would have never lied before in my life.
ReplyDeleteI would share a memory with my brother so he could see how he looked as a baby.
I think this just makes Jonas's experiance scarier because he is probably scared of what he has to lie about.I would want my dad to share a one of he's memorys because he has a very intersting life.
ReplyDeleteWe think Jonas feels very wierd and indevidual beacuse all the others in his community are not allowed to lie and he can and he didn't lie before in he's entire life. We will choose to share our dreams to our sisters because they are allmost in our age and they can understand our way of thinking very well.
ReplyDeleteby: Emmanuelle and MIa
I think Jonas feels a-little uncomforable knowing that he can lie to others and others can't because he seems like a good young man and I don't think he even wants to lie and I think that he doesn't want to be differrent from others (at least not more differrent
ReplyDeletethan waht he is now).
i think I would choose my friend "Li Zebba" beacause we are the best freinds in the world and we tell each-other everything and I know I can trust him because he trusts me.
I think Jonas feels different knowing he can lie from one side but from the other side he may be felt cheated because maybe other people got this saying that they can lie and maybe it could be his parents. I would choose my grandpa because he was in world wore two and I would like to know how was it there and how he survived.
ReplyDeleteI think Jonas is scared to lie. He was educated to not lie and he didn't.It is very scary that now one of the community's biggest rules can be broken easly.
ReplyDeleteI am very interested in my dad's memories, and I would like to know some of his.
I think that Jonas felt weird and different because now he can do something that is not allowed to others, just for him. I think that hhe also felt like he is not going to use this rule to be fair but he is going to lie.
ReplyDeleteI would choose my parents to see how their childhood was and to feel closer to them.
I think jonas feels wierd about the fact that he can, and sometimes will even NEED, to lie to others. he was grown on a place where you should'nt lie, because its breaking the rules of the community.
ReplyDeleteIf I had to chose one person that will share his memories with me, I would prabobly chose some famous person because I'd like to know what its like to be famous.
- I think Jonas feels bad about being allowed to lie and maybe even guilty because he is almost the only one who is allowed to lie in the Community, and he has never lied before.
ReplyDelete- If I could choose one person to share memories with it would be my best friend. I moved to Israel about six months ago and she still lives in America and I would like to send her memories of my life in Israel.
Nir Ofek
ReplyDeleteI think that Jonas was a good boy that following the rules all the time. But now, when he was selected to this special assigment, there was alot of new rules. He can't even imagine how his life would be if he could lie to people. He was confiused and felt uncomftabel.
I would choose someone from my family that could share a memory with me, because its very interesting to hear a story life of someone that I know prettey good. I want to learn about my family background.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletei think Jonas feels diffrent knowing he can lie because he never lied before, but i think he also feels Special because no one else could lie. if i were jonas i would feel diffrerent but in a good way. i would choose my mom because i am talking with her about every thing.she is helping me when i am sad and when i am happy she is supportive meand i love her more then anything.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletei think that jonas would feel very weird that he can lie because he lived in a society in wich lying is a very bad thing. If I would have choose with whom to share my memories i would choose my mom because i would want to experience her memories too.
ReplyDeleteMay Goldberg
ReplyDeleteI think Jonas feel shocked and maybe a little afraid and betrayed. I think that because maybe he’ll think that if he allowed to lie other people allowed to lie, too, like his parents or the Chief Elder. I think that maybe Jonas would be afraid that other lied to him already. If I should choose one person that could share a memory with me I was choosing someone old, but not too old so he\she could clearly remember the memory, for example my grandmother.
I think Jonas is shocked and can't believe that he is allowed to lie, and he won't use it for a while. It was a shock to him because he was educated to not lie, it's like not allowed to buy anything that's more expensive than 10 dollarrs, and one day just get allowed, you won't use it. I would choose Messi, because I want to know what he thinks about Israel.
ReplyDeleteI think Jonas feels shocked and weird by the fact that he can lie. All of his life, he was raised not to lie, and now suddenly he might encounter a situation that he must lie. I think this change, is probably shocking and amazing for him. I would wish to be shared a memory from Julius Cesar, because I would like to experience those ancient times, and how being an emperor feels like.
ReplyDeleteI think Jonas feels freedom that now he doesn’t have to share his dreams and feelings, because if his personal thoughts and feelings will be published it would change people's attitude to him. I think that firstly it would be hard for Jonas to have the opportunity not telling the truth because all his life educated telling the truth.
ReplyDeleteIf I would choose someone that could share with me his memories I would choose someone old, with a fascinating life story, someone who passed many things in his life and there is much to learn from them or from him, someone who has a deferent perspective on life, not like mine.
I think jonas feels freedom and relieved because now he doesn't have to share his dreams anymore. I think he feels special and happy because usually he didn't like sharing his dreams and feelings and now knowing he doesn't have to do it anymore it's a good liberating feeling.
ReplyDeleteThe person I would share my memories and feeling is my mom. She os the closest and most important person for me. I trust her very much and feel comfortable sharing thing with her.
I think that when Jonas is given the permission to lie it makes him rather more separate than the other people, which surely makes him feel more uncomfortable, thinking and wondering of what could be if others had this permission too, and he could never know if what they say is true or false.
ReplyDeleteIf there was one person in the world that I had to share a memory with it would probably be my aunt, not only because I feel good and safe spending time with her, but also she has been in many different places, seen and done exciting things that I wish to know about and experience myself.
I think that Jonas, now that he can lie, thinks that all of his life, he lived in a lie (because everyone can lie). If I (as Jonas) could share a memory, I would share it with Asher, because he deserves to know what am I doing at the Annex room.
ReplyDelete